• Home
  • Products and Services
  • Sales and Consignments
  • Farm Bakery Menu
  • More
    • Home
    • Products and Services
    • Sales and Consignments
    • Farm Bakery Menu
  • Home
  • Products and Services
  • Sales and Consignments
  • Farm Bakery Menu

The Bakery

As a licensed cottage food operation, we are proud to be your local farm bakery offering a diverse selection of baked goods, both sweet and savory, for your enjoyment! While you can find our delicious items at the farm stand during open barn days, we also invite you to take advantage of our special order bakery service for any occasion.

Farm Bakery Menu

Sweet & Savory

Sweet treats and seasonal offerings

Pies

20 each

At our farm bakery, we pride ourselves on using seasonal and locally sourced ingredients whenever possible. Our most popular baked goods include Apple, Peach, Berry, and Pecan pies. Let us know your favorite, and as a special order bakery, we will do our best to accommodate your request.

Donkey Bombs

15/dz

Indulge in our delicious donut style muffin, a delightful addition to our range of baked goods, crafted fresh at our farm bakery. Perfect for those looking to place a special order bakery item for any occasion.

Muffins

22/dz

With or without streusel crumble topping, some of our fan favorites at our farm bakery include Blueberry, Cinnamon, Lemon Poppy, Pumpkin, and Death by Chocolate. Each of these delicious baked goods can also be made available through special order bakery requests.

Scones - sold by the full batch of 6

15/ batch

Whether you prefer blueberry or plain, feel free to let us know your flavor requests! As your local farm bakery, we love to create special order bakery items tailored to your taste.

Blondies and Brownies - sold by the batch

25/ batch

Baked in a 9 x 13 inch pan, these delicious baked goods from our farm bakery are yours to enjoy in their entirety! Try our mouthwatering blondies and brownies, available with or without nuts. For those seeking gluten-free options, don’t miss our rich tuxedo brownies baked in a 9x9 tray, available for special order. Indulge in the sweet offerings from our special order bakery today!

Bars - sold by the batch

35/ batch

Baked in a 9 x 13 inch pan, these delicious baked goods from our farm bakery are yours to enjoy in their entirety! Indulge in our rocky road brownies, savor the delightful carrot cake bars, or treat yourself to our refreshing lemon bars, all available for special order.

Cookies - sold by the dozen

25/ dz

At our farm bakery, we offer a variety of traditional large drop style cookies in many delicious flavors. The classic favorites tend to be chocolate chip, peanut butter, and sugar cookies. If you have a unique flavor in mind, just let us know, and we’d be happy to create a special order bakery treat just for you!

Breads

12/ loaf

Enjoy quick baked goods for your morning (or afternoon or evening) treat from our farm bakery. We sell them by the full loaf, with fan favorites including banana, blueberry lemon, cinnamon, pumpkin, and seasonal fruit available for special order.

Stuffed Breads

24/ loaf

Enjoy our savory stuffed breads made with fluffy bread dough, featuring delicious fillings like cheese and more. Our popular baked goods include options such as pizza bread, broccoli cheddar, and sausage & mushroom. For those looking for something unique, our farm bakery also accepts special order bakery requests—just add $2 per loaf for each additional filling you desire.


Cakes and Cupcakes

Cupcakes - unfilled

25/dz

traditional flavors of baked goods sold by the dozen at our farm bakery, available for special orders.

Cupcakes -filled

35/dz

Enjoy our traditional flavors of baked goods sold by the dozen, filled with your choice of fruit or frosting, available at our farm bakery or through our special order bakery.

Large Cakes - sheet or layer

TBD

Pricing for our baked goods is available upon request at our special order bakery, where we focus on farm-fresh ingredients.

Smash cakes

35

Celebrate with a 6 inch mini 3 layer cake from our farm bakery, perfect for those unforgettable birthday photos! We can even hide a favorite toy inside to keep the party going strong! The price is for basic white icing, with specialty designs available for special order bakery requests.

Contact Us for requests and questions

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

Shagbark Hollow Farm Bethlehem CT


Copyright © 2026 Shagbark Hollow Farm - All Rights Reserved.

Powered by

This website uses cookies.

We use cookies to analyze website traffic and optimize your website experience. By accepting our use of cookies, your data will be aggregated with all other user data.

Accept